Publication: El-i‘câzü’l-belâgî el-kitâbü’s-sânî: el-bâkıllânî- abdülkâhir-es- süyûtî-er-râfiî
Loading...
Files
Date
2022-08-01
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Bu çalışma, Muhammed Muhammed Ebû
Mûsâ’nın el-İ‘câzü’l-belâgî el-kitâbü’s-sânî:el-Bâkıllânî-Abdülkâhir-es-Süyûtî-er-Râfiî adlı eserinin
değerlendirmesinden oluşmaktadır. Kur’an’ın i‘câzını ele alan temel eserlerden dört tanesini mercek
altına alan bu eser, alimlerin konuya yaklaşımını
farklı bir okuma perspektifiyle kritik etmektedir.
Eserlerde geçen açıklamalar, yazarın kendine özgü
üslubuyla tetkik edilmekte; ilk bakışta muğlak ve
girift görülen cümleler ayrıntılı bir şekilde çözümlenmektedir. Yazar kitap boyunca etkili düşünme,
derin okuma ve metinlere nüfuz etme problemleri
üzerinde durmaktadır. Kitabın temel iddiasına göre
retorik anlamda sağlanan üstünlük, ancak aynı dilde
yazılmış iki söz arasındaki seçkinliği saptayan derin
okumayla idrak edilebilir. Kitabın birçok yerinde bu
okumanın gerekliliğine atıf yapılmakta; ayet, hadis
ve şiir örnekleri üzerinden teorik ve pratik boyutuna
değinilmektedir. Çalışmamızda yazarın söz konusu metinlere yaklaşımı ele alınmış ve yazara göre
metinlerin tahlil edilmesinde hangi unsurların zaruri
olduğu değerlendirilmiştir. Yazarın i‘câz meselesini
irdeleyen kitapları nasıl okuduğuna da ayrıca yer
verilmiştir. Sonuç bölümünde ise kitabın misyon ve
vizyonuna atıf yapılarak literatüre katkıları ele alınmıştır.
This article, includes the evaluation of M. Muhammed Ebû Mûsâ’s work named al-İ‘cāz al-Balāghī al-Kitāb al-Thānī: al-Bāqillānī—Abdulqāhir— al-Suyūtī—al-Rāfi‘ī. This book, which examines four of the works that deal with the i’jaz of the Qur’an, criticizes the approach of scholars to the subject from a different reading perspective. The explanations in the works are examined with the author’s unique style; Sentences that seem ambiguous and intricate at first glance are analyzed in detail. Throughout the book, the author focuses on the problems of effective thinking, deep reading and penetrating texts. According to the basic claim of the book, i’jaz and rhetorical superiority can only be realized by deep reading, which determines the superiority between two words written in the same language. The necessity of this reading is referred to in many parts of the book; theoretical and practical dimensions are mentioned. In our study, the author’s approach to the texts is discussed and it is evaluated which elements are necessary in the analysis of the texts according to the author. In addition, it is also mentioned how the author reads the books that examine the issue of i’jaz. In the conclusion part, it was questioned what kind of contribution the book made to the literature by referring to its mission and vision.
This article, includes the evaluation of M. Muhammed Ebû Mûsâ’s work named al-İ‘cāz al-Balāghī al-Kitāb al-Thānī: al-Bāqillānī—Abdulqāhir— al-Suyūtī—al-Rāfi‘ī. This book, which examines four of the works that deal with the i’jaz of the Qur’an, criticizes the approach of scholars to the subject from a different reading perspective. The explanations in the works are examined with the author’s unique style; Sentences that seem ambiguous and intricate at first glance are analyzed in detail. Throughout the book, the author focuses on the problems of effective thinking, deep reading and penetrating texts. According to the basic claim of the book, i’jaz and rhetorical superiority can only be realized by deep reading, which determines the superiority between two words written in the same language. The necessity of this reading is referred to in many parts of the book; theoretical and practical dimensions are mentioned. In our study, the author’s approach to the texts is discussed and it is evaluated which elements are necessary in the analysis of the texts according to the author. In addition, it is also mentioned how the author reads the books that examine the issue of i’jaz. In the conclusion part, it was questioned what kind of contribution the book made to the literature by referring to its mission and vision.
Description
Keywords
: İ‘câzü’l-Kur’ân, Bâkıllânî, Cürcânî, Etkili Okuma, Tefekkür, Inimitability Qur’an, Bāķillāni, Curcani, Deep Reading, Comprehensive Thinking
Citation
ARAZ İ., "EL-İ‘CÂZÜ’L-BELÂGÎ EL-KİTÂBÜ’S-SÂNÎ: EL-BÂKILLÂNÎ- ABDÜLKÂHİR-ES- SÜYÛTÎ-ER-RÂFİÎ", JOURNAL OF ORIENTAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH, cilt.14, sa.2, ss.900-907, 2022